Better Cities Project
  • Home
  • About Us
    Our Vision
    BCP’s vision is that free-market municipal policy solutions are broadly available, widely acceptable, and regularly employed, enabling American cities to achieve their full potential as engines of economic prosperity. We reject the idea that cities are lost to free-market principles or policies.
    Our Mission
    BCP uncovers ideas that work, promotes realistic solutions, and forges partnerships that help people in America’s largest cities live free and happy lives.
    Learn More
    • About Better Cities Project
    • Our Focus Areas
    • Our Team
    • Collaboration and Careers -- Work With BCP
  • Research and Projects
  • Latest Insights
  • Videos
  • Contact

    Address

    304 S. Jones Blvd #2826
    Las Vegas NV 89107

    Phone

    (702) 608-2046‬

    Hours

    Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. - 5 p.m.

    Email

    info@better-cities.org

No Result
View All Result
Better Cities Project
  • Home
  • About Us
    Our Vision
    BCP’s vision is that free-market municipal policy solutions are broadly available, widely acceptable, and regularly employed, enabling American cities to achieve their full potential as engines of economic prosperity. We reject the idea that cities are lost to free-market principles or policies.
    Our Mission
    BCP uncovers ideas that work, promotes realistic solutions, and forges partnerships that help people in America’s largest cities live free and happy lives.
    Learn More
    • About Better Cities Project
    • Our Focus Areas
    • Our Team
    • Collaboration and Careers -- Work With BCP
  • Research and Projects
  • Latest Insights
  • Videos
  • Contact

    Address

    304 S. Jones Blvd #2826
    Las Vegas NV 89107

    Phone

    (702) 608-2046‬

    Hours

    Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. - 5 p.m.

    Email

    info@better-cities.org

No Result
View All Result
Better Cities Project
No Result
View All Result
Home Criminal Justice and Public Safety

Five cities, five different approaches to algorithms in government

Jurisdictions of all sizes are dealing with the advent of unhuman decision-making

Beryl LiptonbyBeryl Lipton
July 30, 2019
in Clean, Open and Fair Government, Criminal Justice and Public Safety
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
Five cities, five different approaches to algorithms in government
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterLinkedInEmail

Can advances in computing help our government better do its job? Across the United States, public officials are betting it can. As they try to incorporate predictive analytics and technology into their operations, each is needing to consider how these non-human actors will be regulated, funded, and made transparent to the public.

We looked at five cities and the steps and policies they’ve considered in their adoption of algorithmic tools.

RelatedInsights

Cities that want to attract business might want to focus less on financial incentives and more on making people feel safe

Lessons from the Bourbon Street truck attack

Soda taxes can become a sticky mess

Documentary: A Tale of Three Cities

New York City, New York: Introducing oversight during implementation

New York City made big headlines with the announcement over a year ago that it would be developing an Automated Decision Systems Task Force to look at existing technologies being used by the City.

“The establishment of the Automated Decision Systems Task Force is an important first step towards greater transparency and equity in our use of technology,” said Mayor Bill de Blasio.

A hotbed of developing AI offerings, the city employs technologies including ShotSpotter gunshot detection and congestion pricing on its toll roads, among an unknown number of other relevant systems. In meetings of the Task Force so far, participants have emphasized the need to inventory and make explainable each of the systems in use.

First, though, the group has needed to focus on identifying what qualifies as an algorithm, a question with which local officials and accountability groups will need to grapple; for now, regulations in many areas are being limited to specific technologies and use cases, rather than the network of possible automated systems. For its purposes, the New York City group has released a checklist of terms and categories that will be relevant to the group’s work.

Columbus, Ohio: Grants drive experimental implementations

Columbus, Ohio was one of seven finalists – alongside Austin, Denver, Kansas City, Pittsburgh, Portland, and San Francisco – for one of the first smart city grant programs hosted by the U.S. Department of Transportation. That award came with $50 million and more than 100 partners cultivated by the city.

Much of that initiative has been communicated through the city’s Smart Columbus website, which also features a collection of open datasets and heavily emphasizes the importance of local, real-time mobility data to developing more efficient transportation systems.

The use of in-the-moment location data is increasingly becoming a part of transportation plans nationwide, sparking concerns about privacy for individuals who may not realize that their locations are being tracked or logged.

Similar privacy concerns spurred technology privacy advocates Electronic Frontier Foundation to file a lawsuit against AT&T last week for its sale of consumer location data, but they have yet to affect the use of real-time location data used in traffic planning, as in the Replica program created by Google’s Sidewalk Labs, which has begun partnerships in Columbus and Portland, Oregon.

Los Angeles, California: Jumping into the deep end

Los Angeles’ employment of algorithms has been one of the widest in America. In addition to its use in transportation, including automated traffic sensors and dynamic tolling, the city and county have been eager to adopt law enforcement technologies like automated license plate readers and PredPol, whose efficacy a recent audit found could not be determined. The West Coast’s largest city quietly entered into an agreement with Axon to be its official AI partner, which includes an agreement to extensively share data with the law enforcement company. The surveillance technologies don’t require specific review by the city council, though legislators in California are currently considering statewide regulation of the technology.

Somerville, Massachusetts: Pressing pause to study the issue

Just north of Boston, the City of Somerville is a community of immigrants, students, blue collar workers, and a growing population of technology workers. It recently took the step of banning facial recognition technology, part of a conversation in the City Council that occurred concurrently with similar talks in San Francisco that ultimately led to restrictions on facial recognition and surveillance technologies.

“There are two issues here. One issue is the existing technologies – there are absolutely no regulations or guidelines for accuracy, for biases, and for democratic oversight. Who can access these databases and under what circumstances?” said Ben Ewan-Campen, the city councilor that put forward the Somerville ordinance.

“And there’s also this issue – even assuming this technology is perfect, is this a power that we want to give to our government, and, if so, under what circumstances? I think neither of those conversations have happened, and yet, we’re seeing it rolled out. And in my opinion, this is the thin edge of the wedge of law enforcement technologies that are brought to market with really no oversight, no transparency, no public conversation around it.”




Somerville’s ordinance does not offer exemptions for law enforcement use, and Ewan-Campen says the city council is also working on a surveillance oversight ordinance that would set transparency standards for all surveillance technologies used by the city.

Spokane, Washington: Discovering the true cost of data

Spokane, Washington had an ambitious plan to develop a pre-trial risk assessment tool, winning a grant from the MacArthur Foundation in order to fund the work. But after three years and millions of dollars, the city found that the necessary data points and upkeep were going to require more money than the city would be able to invest on its own, and the town tossed development of the tool, which had been done in collaboration with the University of Washington.

Soon thereafter, Spokane decided to adopt another pretrial tool, the Arnold Foundation’s PSA, with an additional MacArthur grant, continuing the goal of using the tool to address pretrial detention rates.

“In terms of how community engagement and data collection and analysis relate, I think it’s incredibly important for individuals within the system to understand how the system is operating and how one person’s decision, for instance a prosecutor’s decision, affects the judge’s decision and so on,” said Maggie Yates.

“But it’s also really important with developing transparency with the community and making sure that the community also understands what’s happening within the criminal justice system and across the criminal justice system and also allowing them to understand and see where our initiatives are occurring and what impacts, if any, they’re having.”


This article is reprinted under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Via: MuckRock
Tags: Facial RecognitionPredictive PolicingTechnology
Next Post

How an old zoning concept creates real bottlenecks today

Beryl Lipton

Beryl Lipton

Beryl C.D. Lipton is a senior reporter with The MuckRock Foundation, which manages the day-to-day operations of numerous services in support of a transparent and participatory democracy. She is motivated by the inefficiencies that hinder a progressive democracy, and studied the History and Literature of America at Harvard College.

Explore More

  • Economic Prosperity
  • Criminal Justice and Public Safety
  • Transportation and Infrastructure
  • Education
  • Energy and Environment
  • Community, Growth and Housing
  • Clean, Open and Fair Government

Recent News

I study local government and Hurricane Helene forced me from my home − here’s how rural towns and counties in North Carolina and beyond cooperate to rebuild

I study local government and Hurricane Helene forced me from my home − here’s how rural towns and counties in North Carolina and beyond cooperate to rebuild

May 13, 2025
Texas HB 24: A win for housing development—and a lesson for other cities

Texas HB 24: A win for housing development—and a lesson for other cities

May 7, 2025
Inclusionary housing: At what price?

Inclusionary housing: At what price?

May 5, 2025
Streamlining permits to solve housing shortages

Streamlining permits to solve housing shortages

April 28, 2025
Load More
Facebook Twitter RSS
Better Cities Project

Better Cities Project helps people in America’s largest cities live free, happy lives. We uncover what works, promote solutions, and forge partnerships that turn ideas into results.



© 2023 Better Cities Project

Thanks to QuestionPro for providing us over 35 question types to choose from. The advanced question types help up collect deep insights.

Our Focus Areas

  • Economic Prosperity
  • Criminal Justice and Public Safety
  • Transportation and Infrastructure
  • Education
  • Energy and Environment
  • Community, Growth and Housing
  • Clean, Open and Fair Government

The Fine Print

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Reports and Financials

Recent News

I study local government and Hurricane Helene forced me from my home − here’s how rural towns and counties in North Carolina and beyond cooperate to rebuild

I study local government and Hurricane Helene forced me from my home − here’s how rural towns and counties in North Carolina and beyond cooperate to rebuild

May 13, 2025
Texas HB 24: A win for housing development—and a lesson for other cities

Texas HB 24: A win for housing development—and a lesson for other cities

May 7, 2025
Inclusionary housing: At what price?

Inclusionary housing: At what price?

May 5, 2025

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Love Cities? So Do We.

Get ahead of the curve -- learn about innovations, ideas and policies driving change in America's largest cities, with BCP in your inbox.



You have Successfully Subscribed!

No Result
View All Result
  • About Us
  • The Team
  • Work With Better Cities Project
  • Research and Projects
  • Latest Insights
  • Videos

© 2023 Better Cities Project