Better Cities Project
  • Home
  • About Us
    Our Vision
    BCP’s vision is that free-market municipal policy solutions are broadly available, widely acceptable, and regularly employed, enabling American cities to achieve their full potential as engines of economic prosperity. We reject the idea that cities are lost to free-market principles or policies.
    Our Mission
    BCP uncovers ideas that work, promotes realistic solutions, and forges partnerships that help people in America’s largest cities live free and happy lives.
    Learn More
    • About Better Cities Project
    • Our Focus Areas
    • Our Team
    • Collaboration and Careers -- Work With BCP
  • Research and Projects
  • Latest Insights
  • Videos
  • Contact
    Our Vision

    Address

    304 S. Jones Blvd #2826
    Las Vegas NV 89107

    Phone

    ‪(702) 546-8736‬

    Hours

    Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. - 5 p.m.

    Email

    info@better-cities.org

    Email Us

    No Result
    View All Result
    Better Cities Project
    • Home
    • About Us
      Our Vision
      BCP’s vision is that free-market municipal policy solutions are broadly available, widely acceptable, and regularly employed, enabling American cities to achieve their full potential as engines of economic prosperity. We reject the idea that cities are lost to free-market principles or policies.
      Our Mission
      BCP uncovers ideas that work, promotes realistic solutions, and forges partnerships that help people in America’s largest cities live free and happy lives.
      Learn More
      • About Better Cities Project
      • Our Focus Areas
      • Our Team
      • Collaboration and Careers -- Work With BCP
    • Research and Projects
    • Latest Insights
    • Videos
    • Contact
      Our Vision

      Address

      304 S. Jones Blvd #2826
      Las Vegas NV 89107

      Phone

      ‪(702) 546-8736‬

      Hours

      Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. - 5 p.m.

      Email

      info@better-cities.org

      Email Us

      No Result
      View All Result
      Better Cities Project
      No Result
      View All Result
      Home Community, Growth and Housing

      Book Review: “Arbitrary Lines” by Nolan Gray

      BCP's Patrick Tuohey reviews Grays' recent book on "How Zoning Broke the American City and How to Fix It"

      Patrick TuoheybyPatrick Tuohey
      October 5, 2022
      in Community, Growth and Housing, Economic Prosperity
      Reading Time: 4 mins read
      A A
      Book Review: “Arbitrary Lines” by Nolan Gray
      Share on FacebookShare on TwitterLinkedInEmail

      I wish I had the means to provide copies of Nolan Gray’s book, “Arbitrary Lines” to every local policymaker in the United States. While Gray’s background in city planning and subsequent policy research is evident in his command of the history and intricacies of zoning policy, the book does not require any familiarity with either on behalf of readers. Gray’s prose is clear and approachable—yet Gray himself does not pull any punches in his indictments of zoning.

      From the very beginning, Gray lets you know where he stands. On page 4 he writes, “zoning is perhaps the most successful segregation mechanism ever devised.” He details the history of zoning policy from the early 1900s when it was explicitly racist in cities like Baltimore and Louisville through the 1920s and 30s where—once explicit racial segregation was found to be unconstitutional—economic segregation was used to legally accomplish the same ends.

      Expounding on that point, Gray writes, “zoning is a mechanism of exclusion designed to inflate property values, slow the pace of new development, segregate cities by race and class, and enshrine the single-family house and the exclusive urban ideal” (p30). He details the ways in which this was done, through blocking new housing, mandating that new construction be of a particular quality or lot size, and through a burdensome and unpredictable process of municipal permitting and public approval. As a result, as the population increased housing production failed to keep up. Who can be surprised that there is an affordability crisis?

      RelatedInsights

      Lawsuit: Jacksonville, FL

      Will California Pass Bill Easing Zoning Laws for Church-sponsored Housing Projects?

      Book Review: “The Municipal Financial Crisis” by Mark Moses

      Denver Police Hurt 6 Bystanders in a Shooting. So the City Cracked Down on Food Trucks

      Gray does write a single sentence with which I cannot agree: “The extreme fragmentation of local governance in the United States makes a simple city-by-city approach to zoning reform a nonstarter” (p131). Obviously, we at Better Cities Project are committed to helping city leaders find ways to improve the lives of their communities. However, we appreciate the difficulty of the matter at hand. Anyone working in city hall can appreciate it: from the larger developers who use expensive regulation to keep smaller competition at bay, to those in position to authority who are incentivized to use their position in city government to hand out (and deny!) favors, to those few permanent fixtures at community meetings who use the process to protect their own property values at the expense of nearly everyone else. The good news is that local activists have begun to demand changes in their cities—and have lobbied state legislatures to protect those changes.

      Let me add here that in no way should Gray be understood to be hostile to cities. Time and again Gray indicates his love for cities, their usefulness as job markets and creators of wealth and innovation. Gray mourns for what we have lost by denying the freedom of cities to shape and reshape themselves over time. If anything, “Arbitrary Lines” is a paean to what Harvard Economist Ed Glaeser called “man’s greatest invention” and a prayer that we return to it.

      Certainly, Gray advocates for the complete end to zoning altogether. Before doing so, however, he makes it clear that zoning is often not what we think it to be. It is not the thing that monitors nuisances such as noise or light pollution or protects air and water quality. And he holds up Houston, Texas as an example of how a city without zoning can work to be mindful of neighborhood concerns while at the same time not suffering the same national increase in housing prices and cost of living. In fact, it is Houston’s ability to easily address housing needs that has it’s housing costs so much lower than the national average despite being the 4th populous city in the country.

      But even if zoning were to remain, there is much cites can do. Gray advocates relaxing regulations that require that ONLY single-family detached housing be built—as is the case with about 75 percent of the land in US cities. Even where single family housing is to remain, cities could eliminate or lower minimum lot sizes and floor area, or reduce restrictions on ADUs—accessory dwelling units—that allow homeowners to build onto existing structures or add more units into them.

      Regardless of how we got here, the US is in a housing crunch. This won’t surprise BCP readers, 85 percent of whom indicated in a recent survey that housing affordability is “very much an issue” in your city. Furthermore, over a third (35 percent) indicated that the issue was a failure of public policy. “Arbitrary Lines” details the history of those public policy failings and lays the blame largely at zoning. Certainly we at BCP appreciate the enormous undertaking that such reform would require—but you owe it to yourselves to take a look at Gray’s book. I am confident that you too will want everyone else to read it too. It may not make the solutions any easier—but it will help everyone understand the problem we face.

      Buy a copy of the book.

      Tags: Housing AffordabilityRegulationRental Housing
      Previous Post

      Book Review: “The Municipal Financial Crisis” by Mark Moses

      Next Post

      Lawsuit: Humboldt County, California

      Patrick Tuohey

      Patrick Tuohey

      Patrick Tuohey is co-founder and policy director of the Better Cities Project. He works with taxpayers, media, and policymakers to foster understanding of the consequences — sometimes unintended — of policies regarding economic development, taxation, education, and transportation. He also serves as a senior fellow of municipal policy at the Show-Me Institute, free-market public policy think tank focused on Missouri.

      Explore More

      • Economic Prosperity
      • Criminal Justice and Public Safety
      • Transportation and Infrastructure
      • Education
      • Energy and Environment
      • Community, Growth and Housing
      • Clean, Open and Fair Government

      Recent News

      Lawsuit: Jacksonville, FL

      Lawsuit: Jacksonville, FL

      December 22, 2022
      Will California Pass Bill Easing Zoning Laws for Church-sponsored Housing Projects?

      Will California Pass Bill Easing Zoning Laws for Church-sponsored Housing Projects?

      December 22, 2022
      Lawsuit: Humboldt County, California

      Lawsuit: Humboldt County, California

      October 6, 2022
      Book Review: “Arbitrary Lines” by Nolan Gray

      Book Review: “Arbitrary Lines” by Nolan Gray

      October 5, 2022
      Load More
      Facebook Twitter RSS
      Better Cities Project

      Better Cities Project helps people in America’s largest cities live free, happy lives. We uncover what works, promote solutions, and forge partnerships that turn ideas into results.



      © 2021 Better Cities Project

      Our Focus Areas

      • Economic Prosperity
      • Criminal Justice and Public Safety
      • Transportation and Infrastructure
      • Education
      • Energy and Environment
      • Community, Growth and Housing
      • Clean, Open and Fair Government

      The Fine Print

      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms and Conditions
      • Reports and Financials

      Recent News

      Lawsuit: Jacksonville, FL

      Lawsuit: Jacksonville, FL

      December 22, 2022
      Will California Pass Bill Easing Zoning Laws for Church-sponsored Housing Projects?

      Will California Pass Bill Easing Zoning Laws for Church-sponsored Housing Projects?

      December 22, 2022
      Lawsuit: Humboldt County, California

      Lawsuit: Humboldt County, California

      October 6, 2022
      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • About Us
      • The Team
      • Work With Better Cities Project
      • Research and Projects
      • Latest Insights
      • Videos

      © 2022 Better Cities Project

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password?

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In

      Add New Playlist

      Love Cities? So Do We.

      Get ahead of the curve -- learn about innovations, ideas and policies driving change in America's largest cities, with BCP in your inbox.



      You have Successfully Subscribed!